1

I had a chess position today, in which my last position had 5 possible moves to checkmate. This seemed like a lot to me, and I immediately thought of the puzzle: Which position would yield the maximum number of ways to checkmate the opponent on the next move?

The rules of my made up puzzle are thus

  1. Exactly 1 King per side
  2. Any amount of any other kinds of pieces are allowed for either side
  3. "Score" for the position is the number of winning moves there are

I came up with the following position. By my count, this has 70 total winning moves. I wonder what the maximum would be?

enter image description here

Follow up puzzles which occurred to me:

  1. What's the fewest number of pieces for which every legal move would be checkmate?
    • Pawns aren't allowed
    • Exactly 1 King per side
    • White to move. All black pieces are counted in the answer
    • Alternate rule: you can only have one kind of piece, so there's a unique answer for each kind of piece
  2. What's the fewest number of points for which every legal move would be checkmate?
    • Pawns aren't allowed
    • Exactly 1 King per side
    • White to move. All black pieces' points are counted in the answer
    • Q=9,R=5,B=3,N=3,K=3

Anyone have any suggested solutions to the above puzzles?

Frank Bryce
  • 111
  • 3

2 Answers2

1

Unless I'm misunderstanding the rules, you can easily construct cheap forced mates by

putting white in check: (4 non-Kings, 16 14 points)
enter image description here

And along the same lines, some single-piece boards:

three queens or rooks, five bishops, or five knights should do the trick:
enter image description here

AxiomaticSystem
  • 9,864
  • 16
  • 38
  • Good one. I hadn't considered putting the opposing side in check to force a capture as the only legal move. This is probably (close to?) the optimal solution for the additional puzzles. Perhaps I should've made a separate puzzle Q for each sub-puzzle. – Frank Bryce Apr 29 '21 at 20:21
1

So many questions in one. Here's my answer to the follow-up question(s):

3 pieces, 13 points:

Which can be achieved like this:

enter image description here

White's only legal move is Kxb3#.

Bass
  • 77,343
  • 8
  • 173
  • 360