If one is in middle of Shemoneh Esrei (which is the only part of Tefillah, I could think of where there might be a problem), and there is a life to be saved, is he/she allowed to interrupt the Tefillah in order to go save the life?
Asked
Active
Viewed 437 times
6
-
1I think Krias Shema would have the same implications. – Tzvi May 08 '11 at 03:05
-
@Tzvi How so? - – yydl May 08 '11 at 03:07
-
11What's your hava amina to say that it's different from any other non-big-three, non-shmad-situation Mitzva? – Isaac Moses May 08 '11 at 04:22
-
6My hava amina was coming from the snake in the gemarah (where one cannot be mafsik). Upon further research, though, it's talking about a non-poisonous snake... – yydl May 08 '11 at 04:38
-
Allowed?! Obliged, I should say. – Avrohom Yitzchok Nov 18 '12 at 19:50
-
-1. Good question. But please fix the title so that it contains a question ending with a question mark. Then ping me. – unforgettableidSupportsMonica Aug 06 '13 at 01:14
3 Answers
19
If Pikuach Nefesh pushes off the restrictions of Shabbos, all the more so it pushes off those of Tefila.
Double AA
- 98,894
- 6
- 250
- 713
Gershon Gold
- 139,471
- 12
- 231
- 553
-
3
-
6@yydl: Shabbat is d'oraita, but the specific halachot of tefillah are all d'rabbanan. – Chanoch May 08 '11 at 15:57
-
-
@Adam: He asked about shemoneh esreh specifically. What's d'oraita there that would be a problem? – Chanoch Jul 22 '12 at 11:35
15
A famous halachic rule of thumb:
If someone has to ask his rabbi on questions of ordinary halacha (not murder or the like) vs. any matter of life or limb, shame on the person asking (duh, go save a life!), and shame on the rabbi who should have made that abundantly clear long ago.
So let's get this straight. If a question comes up about violating mitzva X vs. saving life or limb, ask yourself the following four questions about mitzva X:
- Is it murder?
- Is it worshipping idols?
- Is it a major sexual violation, such as adultery or incest?
- Is it giving in to mass attempts to stamp out Judaism?
If you've answered "no" to all four of these questions, hang up the phone and dial 911 (or do whatever else needs to be done).
Are we clear here?
Shalom
- 132,602
- 8
- 193
- 489
-
2There is also the case of Chilul Hashem. Even if its not a mass attempt, if soemone is forcing a Jew to sin (for the sake of sinning) in front of 10 Jews, it is also Yehareg v'al y'avor. – Ariel K Sep 12 '11 at 15:33
-
@Ariel K, I chose the phrase "hang up the phone and dial 911" as often you'll hear it on automated answering systems. In most cases where someone isn't on the phone (they'd better not be on the phone when davening, and now asking if they can interrupt to save a life), they should go pick one up to dial 911. – Shalom Sep 12 '11 at 15:41
1
I heard a hidush on the name of rav ovadia, in case someone is doing shemona esre by heart and in the middle can't remember some part, if there's no sidur in reach he can walk get the sidur, go back to his place and continue, since leaving the place is miderabanan and beracha levatala is mideoraita.
in this case I think you could leave your place do whatever necessary, go back and continue. all of course if you didn't speak. if you did speak that would be more complicated.
also I don't know if asheknezim poskim if beracha levatala is deoraita and if it would make a difference
Avraham
- 1,584
- 9
- 16
-
Your halacha is true, but would not answer the question above. In your case there is no interuption of tefila. In the question, he is interrupting for a different matter. – YDK May 09 '11 at 13:06
-
what I mean is that is he doesn't interrupt by speaking he could continue – Avraham May 10 '11 at 12:46