2

On reading the old Journey into Mystery comics, where Thor first appeared, it is not evident that the Asgardians are aliens. As far as the audience can tell, they are simply the Norse gods of myth.

When in comic history were the Asgardians revealed to be aliens rather than gods?

Valorum
  • 689,072
  • 162
  • 4,636
  • 4,873
Donatello Swansino
  • 19,758
  • 13
  • 95
  • 166
  • 2
    You are comparing the MCU with the main Marvel comics continuity. They are not like for like. – K Mo May 11 '20 at 18:24
  • @KMo I know that they aren't identical, but in this instance I'm pretty sure it's a carry-over from the comics. – Donatello Swansino May 11 '20 at 18:49
  • If you are asking are the Asguardians from Marvel comics aliens (like in the MCU) not gods and if so when did it change, your question should specify that. – K Mo May 11 '20 at 18:55
  • @Skooba - What;s confusing the issue for me is that Thor is the son of an Asgardian and a literal Goddess whereas the average Asgardian isn't. So the question of whether Thor is a god (or rather demi-god) is a different question from whether an Asgardian is a god. – Valorum May 11 '20 at 22:23
  • As the question is a 'when did they start being portrayed this way' as opposed to 'are they gods or aliens', I think the possible dupe mentioned by @Skooba is effectively a dupe of this question. – K Mo May 12 '20 at 00:55

1 Answers1

1

In the 1999 miniseries Earth-X (now officially designated as Earth-9997), the Celestials had long-ago implanted an egg within the Earth that would eventually hatch into a new Celestial. In order to protect the egg, they modified humans to have the capacity to develop superpowers either through evolution (thus Marvel's Mutants) or through some kind of trigger, such as the assorted characters with some kind of empowering origin story, such as the Hulk, the goal being that the empowered humans would protect the Earth from external (and internal) threats, unknowingly protecting the egg that would, eventually, destroy the planet when it hatched.

However, these empowered humans could theoretically develop Celestial-level powers, so the Celestials implanted a psychological failsafe where the expression of an individual's power was self-crippled so an individual with power only expressed it in a specific way at a specific level because that's what they thought their power was, not what their power actually is. So, theoretically, Peter Parker could be omnipowerful: a psychic like Professor X, healing powers like Wolverine, Reed Richards level genius, as stronger as the Hulk, so on and so forth, all dialed up to over 9000 (sorry, OVER 9000!), but because the triggering of his power was due to the bite of the spider, he psychologically limited himself to spider-like abilities (with some exceptions like his spider-sense).

Loki eventually discovered that humans weren't the only ones this had happened to: the Celestials did the same thing everywhere they implanted their eggs. He discovered that eventually beings who had been so manipulated, if they survived the hatching of a Celestial on their world, eventually metamorphosed into no longer being mortal, but in doing so became a mental blank slate when it came to their personal image, which changed based on the people around them, and then became self-reinforcing. So, the Asgardians weren't gods, they were a group of these aliens who encountered humans who believed they were gods, and thus they took on those personas, adopting their powers and psychologies to suit the beliefs of the humans, and this became self-reinforcing. Loki wasn't originally an evil trickster god, he was an alien that humans decided was an evil trickster god, and thus he became one. And the Celestial psychological trap slammed shut again.

(Incidentally, he also discovered Odin had been a normal human who had realized what was happening and exploited it, making the aliens unwittingly give him some of their power. This is why he underwent the Odinsleep whereas other Norse gods did not; he needed to do it to replenish the power he'd taken from them that made him immortal.)

Loki's realization was that all of Earth's gods and devils and demons were similarly other alien refugees who had taken on personas and believed that's what they were. He went around trying to fruitlessly convince beings like Mephisto that he wasn't inherently a manipulative evil demon and certainly didn't have to stay that way, but the beings who had changed now had such a strong self-image, because of the Celestial failsafe, that he was unsuccessful trying to do so.

So, long answer, that was one example where the Asgardians (and the Olympians, and every other pantheon, god, devil and other "supernatural" creature) were revealed to really just be aliens who had, unintentionally, been forced into those roles.

Malady
  • 3,675
  • 15
  • 32
Keith Morrison
  • 21,361
  • 1
  • 60
  • 77
  • While this is true of the universe Earth/Universe/Paradise X is set in, it no longer lines up with the main Marvel comic universe 616. For example in universe 9997, the aliens who would become asgardians met humans who had already developed the Norse mythology and IRC had metal weapons and lived in wooden huts. While in universe 616, Odin was visiting the earth around 1,000,000 BC. – K Mo May 11 '20 at 22:55
  • I explicitly pointed that out. – Keith Morrison May 12 '20 at 14:13
  • The Earth X timeline was once considered one of the miriad of possible future timelines of the main continuity. Therefore anything mentioned as happening in the past could have been tentatively considered cannon. I only wished to point out that the histories of both universes have now diverged showing them to have completely different histories for anyone coming across this answer in the future. I wasn't disagreeing with your answer in the context you set out. – K Mo May 12 '20 at 14:35