27

In the Voyager episode The Q and the Grey, Q wants to have a child with Janeway because there hasn't been a new Q in billions of years and he wants to mix up the Continuum (to save it). But this statement would seem to over look Amanda Rogers from True Q (TNG).

Is there a canon explanation for this conflict of facts, or was this merely an oversight on the part of the writers?

Xantec
  • 61,649
  • 46
  • 259
  • 438

2 Answers2

16

From the synopsis of True Q that you linked to:

[Q] then reveals that Amanda is a Q, shocking everyone else. When Crusher claims Amanda's birth parents were Human, Q reveals they were members of the Q Continuum who had assumed Human form.

I can only surmise that since both Amanda's parents were members of the Q Continuum that in that case there was no introduction of the human DNA that he was looking for with Janeway.

This is further evidenced by:

...the real reason for [Q's] examination was to determine if Amanda was actually a Q or some sort of hybrid that would have to be exterminated.

He is sent there to make sure that she is not a hybrid but a full "Q".

From The Q and the Grey:

He then explains that he wishes to end the war by adding Human DNA into the Continuum and having a baby, something that hasn't been done before.

The episode does end with the "solution" being Q mating with a female Q, however it is not stated that this act of procreation had "never been done before" but rather that adding human DNA had not.

Edit: As pointed out by @bitmask in the comments, there also was a difference in the erm...mating procedures for the two "Q" children. Which may lead to Q's presumption that what he was wont to do had not been done before: E.T. and Star Wars are in the same universe but I don't think E.T. and Star Trek are, so the mating ritual was unique in-universe.

Community
  • 1
NominSim
  • 29,972
  • 7
  • 128
  • 140
  • 3
    In addition to this explanation: It is reasonable to assume Amanda was conceived while her parents were in human form, using conventional human means. Junior however was conceived with the weird E.T. technique. So that should make a difference. – bitmask May 30 '12 at 18:03
  • 6
    The fact that having a child with Lady Q appeased Q's desire for a child makes me wonder whether the desire for human DNA was actual, or if mentioning that was simply Q attempting to appeal to Janeway and make her more amenable to the proposition. – Xantec May 30 '12 at 18:07
  • 12
    @Xantec ... new pick up line for the bars? "I desire the addition of your human DNA, it's never been done before." – NominSim May 30 '12 at 18:10
  • 4
    @NominSim: I see that line working very well for women, but not on women. ;) – gnovice May 30 '12 at 18:12
  • 4
    @gnovice That is basically the plot of Species – NominSim May 30 '12 at 18:13
6

To pull a quote directly from The Q and the Grey:

"Even if I wanted to mate, I wouldn't know how. It's totally unprecedented." - Q

"You'll figure something out. You are omnipotent, after all." - Janeway

"I need time to think about it." - Q

What has never been done before, was two Q having a child. Amanda Rogers' parents did choose human form, and conceived her as humans. And as we saw in Deja Q, the Q have no difficulty in becoming human.

There's even a quote from Q in True Q that supports this (emphasis mine):

They had assumed human form, in order to visit Earth, I suppose. For.. for amusement. But in vulgar human fashion, they proceeded to conceive a child. And then like mawkish humans, they became attached to it.

This is further supported in the series of (non-canon) novels The Q Continuum, where the female Q from The Q and the Grey states that Amanda Rogers "doesn't count".

So no, the Q didn't forget about Amanda Rogers. She just wasn't conceived of two Q.

Community
  • 1
Izkata
  • 60,194
  • 14
  • 205
  • 303