0

I've heard that human cone cells can detect only one color, so it's more like a Bayer sensor than a Foveon. So, if the human eye is close to the Bayer sensor, I wondered if color moire would occur in the human eye as in the attached photo. Will the human eye use a feature like a low pass filter like most cameras to solve this problem?

text text

bayer                     foveon

source : https://sudonull.com/post/184570-Hybrid-film-and-CCD-CMOS-matrix-is-not-possible-Try-saying-it-Foveon-X3

upyen
  • 1
  • Please see Filter for RGB separation and its effect on the image for how both the cones in the human retina and the color-filtered photosites on Bayer masked sensors create color out of specific combinations of wavelengths of light. Your question makes some rather misinformed assumptions about both. Hint: the peak sensitivities for our S, M, and L cones are not R, G, and B. Neither are the peak transmissivity of the three colors used in a Bayer mask, all the cute little pictures of red, green, and blue squares on the internet notwithstanding. – Michael C Feb 01 '21 at 17:21
  • Neither our cones nor the photosites behind color filters of Bayer masks are only sensitive to one color, either. They both have a LOT of overlap in the wavelengths to which each is sensitive. – Michael C Feb 01 '21 at 17:34

2 Answers2

7

It's more complicated than this because:

  1. Moiré appears when there is a slight difference of spatial frequency between the image and the sensor. But the cones and the rods, being organic, are not in a neatly equally spaced grid so you cannot define a spatial frequency for them (or at least there is a frequency range so the moiré is severely attenuated).

  2. Our eyes are in constant movement so the image isn't fixed on the retina and any moiré would be a very transient effect.

xenoid
  • 21,297
  • 1
  • 28
  • 62
  • Re #2. Moving the camera while shooting video with a camera that has a Bayer filter, but no AA filter, does not hide moire. – xiota Feb 01 '21 at 16:47
  • Re #1. Autochrome has randomly distributed color filters. – xiota Feb 01 '21 at 16:49
  • @xiota Moving the camera does shift the shape and location of the moire, though. – Michael C Feb 01 '21 at 17:35
  • 1
  • The image is really created in the brain. The eyes are delivering visual information that the brain interprets to form a full image. So even if the eyes would see a moire pattern, the brain would probably ignore it.
  • – Pete Feb 02 '21 at 07:52
  • Re #1, Fuji created the X-trans sensor (which is not a bayer based sensor), that has a layout that should minimise moire. In fact to such a degree that they don't put a low pass filter in front. – Pete Feb 02 '21 at 07:58