0

Follow up to this M.Y. question.

In summary, Pirkei Avot says that we should not compare "major" vs. "minor" mitzvoth for we don't know the reward given to mitzvoth.

Frequently, we actually DO equate two mitzvoth. If one is in a situation where he has to violate a mitzvah, one is Rabbinical and one is Torah-based, usually, one violates the Rabbinical one. Generally, less importance is placed on the Rabbinical mitzvoth than the Torah ones.

My rav explained to me that because of this perceived lack of importance, there are many cases where the rabbis placed heavy or more emphasis on performing a rabbinical mitzvah over a Torah-based one.

An example that I can think of - There are some opinions that state that the mitzvah of studying Torah is from the Torah. Reading the Megillah on Purim is Rabbinical. However, O.C. (I'll edit location, later, B"N) says that one needs to stop studying Torah in order to read the Megillah when the time to do so has arrived.

So, in general, if one has a choice (unlike, the above example, where no "choice" is given) between performing a Rabbinical or Torah mitzvah, does the adage of Pirkei Avot that one should not equate the two apply to this choice as well? Or should one favor the Torah-based one at all times?

wfb
  • 14,504
  • 43
  • 76
DanF
  • 70,416
  • 8
  • 59
  • 244
  • Mid'oraisa, mid'rabanan...What's the difference between a mitzvah and a mitzvah? However, to the random downvoter: why did you not leave a comment when you downvoted? – ezra Jun 04 '17 at 06:43
  • @ezra There is a difference, as I mentioned in the question. And, in fact, we do prioritize, often. In terms of the context of this question, it appears that making this priority may be a contradiction of the adage. – DanF Jun 05 '17 at 14:19
  • When I think major mitzvos, I think of mitzvos like tefillin, taharas mishpacha, Shabbos...When I think of minor mitzvos, I think "do not muzzle the oxen" and "do not shave between your eyes." – ezra Aug 23 '17 at 18:58
  • @ezra See the question that I linked to. It's a different angle than the one, here. – DanF Aug 23 '17 at 19:00
  • @ezra Perhaps the downvoter was motivated by the numerous mistakes in the question. I will list those that come to mind: 1) Studying Torah is a mitsvah d'orayta according to all opinions, (a side point). 2) Torah study being nidhe to Megillah reading is a horrible example of the relative merits of biblical and rabbinic mitsvot, as Torah study is nidhe to every mitsvah, biblical or rabbinic that cannot be performed by others. – mevaqesh Aug 23 '17 at 19:33
  • The actual halakha in question doesnt even have to do with Torah vs. Megillah, but with Torah vs. gathering a minyan for the reading, (as the Rishonim explain) which is not a rabbinic obligation, and hence independent of the question. None of it has to do with anything to do with adding stringency to rabbinic laws so they arent disregarded. 4) The Mishna never says one shouldn't equate major and minor mitsvot. I have no idea what that means, but it isnt what the Mishna says. Maybe he means you should equate which isnt what the Mishna says either.
  • – mevaqesh Aug 23 '17 at 19:33
  • On further thought, I think he is just misusing the word 'equate', but that still isnt what the Mishna says. 6) The basic premise that according to the Mishna, among non-rabbinic mitsvot, one shouldn't prefer one mitsvah to another if one has the choice, is wrong, and not the intent of the Mishna, according to the post which he himself marked correct there.
  • – mevaqesh Aug 23 '17 at 19:33
  • @mevaqesh It's a bit tough for me to digest all this from your 3 comments. But, by all means, refute my assumption. I'm looking forward to it :-) – DanF Aug 23 '17 at 19:36
  • @mevaqesh - Over achiever. :P – ezra Aug 23 '17 at 20:13
  • @ezra לפום צערה אגרא – DanF Aug 23 '17 at 20:59
  • @DanF - :) LOL. I'm sure it caused mevaqesh lots of pain to type all that up. – ezra Aug 23 '17 at 21:05
  • @wfb https://www.sefaria.org/Sukkah.25a.4 and (second paragraph here:) http://chabadlibrary.org/books/adhaz/sh/sh5/6/4/3.htm – hazoriz Aug 24 '17 at 08:47