Are the comments of Tosfos in the same Mesechta generally considered to be aligned, meaning that, if there is an apparent contradiction, we try and look for a resolution?
How about Tosfos in different Mesechtas?
Asked
Active
Viewed 151 times
3
-
2Related: http://judaism.stackexchange.com/q/17347 – msh210 Dec 04 '13 at 07:40
-
1@msh210 I think Yahu's answer there works here too. – WAF Dec 04 '13 at 12:28
-
possible duplicate of Who is the voice of Tosafoth? – termsofservice Dec 04 '13 at 22:41
-
@WAF yes I agree with you, I just saw that question, looked up the sefer that Yahu says, hopefully will get to reading it soon, however just at a quick glance, he has a chapter where he goes through the different Tosfos authors by Mesechta and identifies (at least Meseches Berachos, which is what I was learning) as having one author/editor. – termsofservice Dec 04 '13 at 22:44
-
http://www.hakirah.org/Vol15Leibowitz.pdf – termsofservice Dec 04 '13 at 23:06
-
@Efraim, related, but not a duplicate. There could be different answers to this question for any given answer to that question. – Isaac Moses Dec 05 '13 at 18:40
1 Answers
2
I recall a place in Bava Kamma where R' Akiva Eiger points out that Tosfos in two different chapters are clearly saying opposite things -- and we just assume that was due to two different authors/editors.
Shalom
- 132,602
- 8
- 193
- 489
-
2
-
that happens a lot, I'll just give one more example the second gilyon hashas on daf 2. berachos, and meforshim on him explain how their is no contradiction between the tosfos, so that is not a conclusive proof – termsofservice Dec 04 '13 at 22:40