2

Hinduism acknowledges god as omnipresent - he is present everywhere and in every soul. He is said to have created the cosmos. Then, why did he create demons and does he manifests in demons too?

Good Guy
  • 356
  • 1
  • 12
  • https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Problem_of_evil_in_Hinduism – Vineet Menon Jun 14 '16 at 08:41
  • Dear Vineet, The link you sent talks about the presence of injustice in the world which is not to be present if there were an omnipresent god and the arguments for and against the omnipresence of God. However, the post only describes injustice and karma and not evil. Please note that evil is not injustice. Karma though obscure, is not blind. – Good Guy Jun 14 '16 at 09:12
  • AFAIK, in Hinduism, every soul has the ability to move up and down the echolons, so one may be a human in this life but could potentially end up being the Indra or because of his bad karma could also end up being a pichasa in next janma. – Vineet Menon Jun 14 '16 at 10:21
  • Dear Vineet, Why would the Lord create demons from sinned souls and ostracise them? Demons join hands and wreak havoc on heaven and earth. The Lord has to go with his army to kill them. Why would the Lord create his own enemies? – Good Guy Jun 14 '16 at 10:40
  • 1
    Brahman doesn't punish men for their deeds, the law of Karma does. You don't blame gravity for a stone hitting you when you yourself had thrown it up, do you? Similarly, the law of Karma is eternal, like a cosmic order of things. – Vineet Menon Jun 14 '16 at 12:33
  • Vineeth, the Lord has control over karma. Why would he allow it to create demons who would later cause chaos and destruction? – Good Guy Jun 14 '16 at 12:43
  • 2
    Good question, why has God created demons, if He is good? Here are three explanations (out of many). 1. Who is God? if God is an external entity, then this is a valid question, however God is not separate from you, says Advaita. Then this question comes to a halt immediately, the better question is why have You created evil? 2. Who is a demon? If demon means a bad person, then the question arises 'what is bad?'. if you see something or someone as 'bad' then that is your perspective. According to the bad person you are the bad one. So how can you answer this? Again the question halts. – Sai Jun 14 '16 at 16:54
  • 1
  • Who created what? If God created demons then this is a valid question. However, all the jivas (including demons) have always been in existence since the begining ot time (Gita 15:6). So the jivas have always been in existence, following their own Will (according to their vasanas). Based on their actions, they reap the karmas. So in other words 1. God did not create demons. 2. Demons don't see the need to do good, only you do. From their perspective, you need not exist, but you still do. 3. Would you watch a movie without drama? That's why you have created demons in 'Your Movie'.
  • – Sai Jun 14 '16 at 17:01
  • @GoodBoy, You might need to read this. https://journals.denison.edu/religion/2015/04/17/evil-and-theodicy-in-hinduism-by-sunder-willett-15/. The problem is you are thinking in terms of a Christian perspective. Hinduism is much more fluid and malleable in the the moral/evil department. BTW, the question you are raising is called theodicy. – Vineet Menon Jun 15 '16 at 04:55
  • 1
    @Sai We are the machine, God is the operator. We simply don't have an individual power to act. Whatever God wants us to do, we'll do. We cannot think on our own so we can't do any good or bad. Moreover, my actions are fixed from the beginning, that's why Swami Vivekananda said that future telling is possible. So if someone does good or bad, it is already fixed. The question arises - what is the need for karma when every single action is fixed? – Pinakin Jun 15 '16 at 08:14
  • 1
    @ChinmaySarupria Well said :). What is the need for karma when every single action is fixed? Good point. There are two levels here. For the one who does not believe that God is the operator, he has given himself the role of doership. For him, there may appear to be karma. For he seems to enact his will, rather than 'His Will'. Such sadhakas are usually karma yogis. However for the one who has realized that God is the doer, for him everything is God's Will. Karma becomes an optional belief. Everything is part of God's plan. Your perspective is the ParaBhakta's perspective. All the best. – Sai Jun 15 '16 at 13:38