What can I substitute for Guanciale?

Question

Guanciale is something I've never seen in the UK. What can I use as a substitute?

Or, alternatively, is there somewhere I can source this in the UK?

Note: I'm thinking of experimenting with an Amatriciana.

Answer 1

Wikipedia suggests Pancetta which is another form of cured Italian bacon, usually without smoking. I think the primary thing you are looking for is cured but not smoked, as smoke will add a strong flavor that is completely missing in Guanciale.

Answer 2

America's Test Kitchen recommends well rinsed salt pork as a substitute for guanciale in Amatriciana.

Answer 3

In Italy, Amatriciana is quite often cooked with pancetta cubes (smoked or not).

Here in the UK, if you can't find pancetta (easily found at Waitrose or Tesco), you can also substitute with lardons, bacon cubes or streaky bacon strips. The overall effect is very similar - however I suggest that you try guanciale if you can find it.

Answer 4

Pork belly! Very similar to guanciale, maybe slightly less fat.

Answer 5

There really isn't a good substitute for Guanciale, but it can be purchased online.

For example http://laquercia.us/cuts_specialties_guanciale_and_lardo_guanciale_americano.

Or in the UK http://www.nifeislife.com/advanced_search_result.php?keywords=guancial

Answer 6

Yes, you can substitute Guanciale with Pancetta cured Italian bacon but usually without smoking.

If you are in the UK you can be got it online, See the Balsamic Vinegar Recipes with Pancetta http://blog.vorrei.co.uk/balsamic-vinegar-recipes/