Questions tagged [defense]

Questions relating to the defense of a thesis and the process surrounding it, such as the grading system of a thesis, who may come to a thesis defense, the duration of a thesis defense session, etc.

According to caltech

The main purpose of the [...] Thesis Defense is to have a committee of faculty examine the doctoral candidate on the scope of the thesis and its significance in relation to the major subject.

Some further detail from The University of New South Wales

The thesis defence or viva is like an oral examination in some ways. It is different in many ways, however. The chief difference is that the candidate usually knows more about the syllabus than do the examiners. Consequently, some questions will be sincere questions: the asker asks because s/he doesn't know and expects that the candidate will be able to rectify this.

165 questions
18
votes
3 answers

Ask supervisor *not* to come to viva?

My viva is coming up, and one of my supervisors is planning to attend. I know that he won't be able to say anything during the viva itself, but I'm a little worried what he might say afterward while the examiners are discussing my fate. He's a good…
LaVivaLoca
  • 183
  • 1
  • 5
17
votes
1 answer

Time short on thesis defense preperation

I was supposed to defend my thesis in another week. But, due to the time schedule of one of the committee members I have to give the defense it tomorrow. My status: Developed a rough defense presentation (probably need revision) Have less than a…
vulkkan
  • 427
  • 3
  • 9
9
votes
5 answers

My mum was recently diagnosed with cancer. Should I tell my supervisor?

Yesterday, my mum was recently diagnosed with cancer. However, we have yet to know what stage is her cancer and whether the cancer can still be removed from her body or it has metastasized to other parts of organs. This is a major health concern and…
alex
  • 973
  • 2
  • 9
  • 20
5
votes
3 answers

Why do supervisors hide my rights from me?

the question title above is deliberately provocative. I am in the UK. A few days ago I have explained my situation - many problems with a Department that was not able to support me adequately. Generally, both my supervisor, co-supervisor (the…
TakeMeToTheMoon
  • 641
  • 5
  • 14
3
votes
3 answers

Are you unofficially a PhD holder after passing viva voce for PhD?

In my university, after passing a viva voce examination, it will take more than 3 months before the university issues an official letter/transcript/certificate to certify that one is officially a PhD holder. Of course, after PhD viva, it will take…
alex
  • 973
  • 2
  • 9
  • 20
3
votes
1 answer

Some of the major corrections are already in the thesis

I've passed my viva with major corrections at a UK university. Upon receiving the corrections, I found some of them were already emphasised and discussed in several places in the thesis. My supervisor said I should just accept these corrections and…
user96201
  • 31
  • 1
2
votes
3 answers

My department delayed my viva and is being unprofessional. Should I report this?

I submitted my PhD thesis to my department last August for examination. However, I found out from my supervisor that my department only sent my thesis to examiners last November for examination. So it took them about 3 months to get my thesis to…
alex
  • 973
  • 2
  • 9
  • 20
1
vote
1 answer

Stress and anxiety while waiting for PhD viva

I submitted my PhD thesis more than a month ago. I was told by the Postgraduate Department that I would have my oral examination in six weeks. It's been six weeks already and I haven't heard any news. I heard from former students that in some cases,…
alex
  • 973
  • 2
  • 9
  • 20
1
vote
2 answers

What's the purpose of a PhD defense?

It looks like everyone has it's own theories on what's the function of a defense. People say that it has to be a contribution to knowledge, other people say that it has to reflect 3 years of work, other say that it has to be a work of publishable…
TakeMeToTheMoon
  • 641
  • 5
  • 14